The Broken Spears Chapters 1-7 Reflection

I found the readings in chapters 1-7 to be very thought-provoking. It opened up a new view for me of the arrival of Cortes and the Spaniards. I found it very interesting to learn about the omens and wonders and now see that it was in a way foreshadowing the future events. It was unique to read about what their first reactions were to the Spaniards arriving (the mountains floating in the water) because they had never seen such large boats before. It is very amusing that Motechuzoma instructed many different people to watch for the ships to see if they too could see the sight they had never seen before. It was interesting to see from his point of view as a ruler, the fear of this arrival of the unknown and his ways of going about “welcoming” them by presenting them with gifts. Though Motechuzoma feared the Spaniards it seems as though Cortes and his followers did not fear Motechuzoma and his people. At some parts of the reading, I found it hard to imagine dealing with different battles and different threats of killing off families and homes. However, in the end, I did find the reading overall to be very informative and different in it’s views. It gave a more personal one on one view of emotions, fears, and events of the arrival of the Spaniards.

The TRUE Importance of Christopher Columbus

I found the homework reading, The True Importance of Christopher Columbus to be very interesting yet frustrating at the same time. I found it interesting because there were a lot of facts and details given that I had never before heard of or realized. I was in complete agreement after reading the article as to the author’s standpoint on textbooks. A lot of the things that were pointed out as things that were learned in education previous to college I found myself recalling. I can remember learning all of the obvious things about Columbus that were stated as common in this reading. However, I did find it frustrating to feel as though I, along with many others, have been kept in a way behind the scenes while dealing with Columbus, history, and it’s details. It’s almost aggravating to find that a lot of the things I have learned have somewhat seemed to be misrepresented in a way. I am interested however to find out more about the previous journeys to the America’s by others and reasons behind it.

Bardic & Analytic Interpretations of the Columbian Voyages

In the first chapter of Crosby’s writing, I found it very interesting/surprising that there are two different and distinct interpretations of the Columbian Voyages. It is stated that the bardic version is the version that most of us grew up learning and hearing about. I find it odd, and a bit disappointing that through many years of education, I have been taught the more positive version of the story, leaving out any negative events. (For example: Columbus discovering the “New World” and the division made between the Europeans leaving out the effects that the arrival had on the native inhabitants.) The reading indicated that the bardic authors or historians focused more on heroism than anything else.
The newer version, or the analytical interpretations used different methods than pervious. I feel that all for the fact that it tries to understand and develop what kind of impact the arrival had on those native inhabitants whether it be positive or negative should explore this version more. (For example: the role that sickness and disease may have played on the original inhabitants.)Basically I believe that the newer version or view needs to be explored more than anything showing all aspects of the arrival. I was never really in complete agreement to Columbus and the praise the he receive(d).